HECKENLIVELY ON THE OMNIBUS AUTISM PROCEEDING: 5/28
RECOVERY STORY: MITCHELL

DAVID KIRBY: RIP TIM RUSSERT

Tim_russertBy David Kirby

Tim Russert was the kindest journalist I ever met, and being on his show was the highlight of my career.

I will never forget his humanity, compassion, intelligence and open mind. His passing is a huge loss for America, democracy, and the world.

In his honor, I reprint here my take on appearing on Meet the Press, from the Huffington Post.

My Take on Tim
Posted August 9, 2005


Don’t tell Arianna, but I like Tim Russert.

Yes, I am extremely biased, on account of Russert inviting me onto his prestigious show and holding up a copy of my book, “Evidence of Harm,” to a bleary eyed, Sunday morning America. And yes, I agree that Russert could go further and hit harder at times in his follow-up questions and cross-examinations of leading political figures. But in my humble opinion, I think he did a terrific job last Sunday on “Meet the Press.” He is to be commended for bringing this serious and urgent debate to the prominence that I, for one, believe is merited.

Last Sunday, “Meet the Press” made history in the annals of autism, journalism, and the American people by bringing together two parties, face-to-face, for the first time to rationally discuss the evidence for and against a link between mercury in vaccines and the explosion of reported autism cases in the United States: And all on national broadcast television (and internationally on MSNBC), no less.

The hundreds of comments I have received on the show are very telling in terms of assessing Tim Russert’s impartiality in covering this story. Some people felt that Russert gave Dr. Harvey Fineberg, President of the Institution of Medicine, extra speaking time out of reverence for his lofty position in science and public health, or perhaps in deference to pharmaceutical advertisers on NBC. But an equal number of people thought that Russert had let Dr. Fineberg give his rather long-winded and circuitous answers without interruption, in order to make it seem like he was flapping and spinning (to borrow a term from the autism world). In other words, the old “give ‘em enough rope” theory.

I don’t ascribe personally to either theory, at least as far as my own experience was concerned. That 20 minutes flies by faster than it takes to reach the end of this sentence. Really. Russert had a lot of questions to ask, and I understand the instinct to move forward against the clock. I was in the same position, wanting to question Dr. Feinberg on many of his statements, but also wanting to move forward to make my own. Incidentally, my four points, boiled to their essence and, I think, unassailable, were: 1) Mercury is toxic and kids got too much of it; 2) We need to look at biology and toxicology (in addition to population studies); 3) This process has lacked transparency; 4) Listen to the parents.”

One more word on Russert’s behalf, before the angry comments start pouring in. This is a hugely complicated and controversial topic, and most people in the mainstream media have been loathe to touch it. To their immense credit, people like Don Imus, Robert Kennedy, Jr., Joe Scarborough, Montel Williams, Ron Reagan and Monica Crowley have also brought this story to national television. It is not an easy topic to cover, but they all recognized it as important.

I notice that the tone of the comments posted on this blog in opposition to this theory (and please folks, look up the meaning of “theory” before you sharpen your knives) have become angrier and more accusatory as time goes on. Shooting the messenger is a great American pastime, and I have no problem with it. But try to listen to the message, too. It actually comes in the form of a question:

“Why is it so controversial to suggest that a known neurotoxin injected directly into the systems of pregnant women, newborns and infant children above federal safety levels MIGHT have caused a neurological disorder in a subset of children with a genetic predisposition against metabolizing mercury efficiently?”

And if mercury is not a contributing factor to some cases of autism, (which could be the case, but I am starting to doubt it), then what is? And where are the laboratory and clinical studies proving that thimerosal is safe, anyway?

David Kirby is a contributor to Age of Autism and the author of Evidence of Harm.

Comments

Lisa

So sad to hear the news about Tim. H

He was AMAZING. His commentary. His intellect. I enjoyed watching him go after both sides of the aisle on a regular basis. There is are some extremely large shoes to fill. He was a true journalist (unlike many of the ones that are either lazy or bought and paid for.) He investigated issues and was kind to the Autism Community.

I am so sad for his family. He was way too young.

Becky Estepp

David, that Sunday in August of 2005 was one the best days of my life. I was so happy to be in DC that day and to be able to watch MTP with you as it aired. When you told me how wonderful Tim Russert had been to you, I gained only more admiration for that truly remarkable man. I remember you told me that Tim had you sign his EOH book. And you said, "Can you imagine, ME, signing a book for Tim Russert?" I said, "Of course, but that doesn't mean that it is any less cool." I will really miss watching Tim on MTP on Sundays. What a loss.

dan o.

i agree. what a loss. elevating the discussion to "meet the press" was one of the breakthroughs in this whole long saga and he did do a very good job.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)