The Perry Mason Moment - Day Ten of the Autism Onmibus Trial
The Numbers Game – Day Eleven of the Autism Omnibus Trial

SNAPE? Good or evil? Ask Autism Speaks.

Picture_030_2By Kim Stagliano

In the spirit of the newest Harry Potter book, Autism Speaks kindly tied Snape with autism so I could dream up that snappy (Snapey?) headline about dark magic unfolding before us.

The Chair of Autism Speaks Treatment board is Eric Hollander. Professor Hollander has been associated with a British Company called Neuropharm since its inception. Here's what Neuropharm writes about him on their site:

"Professor Eric Hollander
Autism Programme Consultant

Professor Eric Hollander is Esther and Joseph Klingenstein Professor and Chairman of Psychiatry at the Mount Sinai School of Medicine (MSSM) in New York City. He is also Director of the Seaver and Greater New York Autism Center of Excellence (NIH STAART Center) and Director of Clinical Psychopharmacology at MSSM. Professor Hollander serves as a reviewer for 8 medical journals and has published more than 450 scientific reports in the psychiatric field. He recently edited the textbook Autistic Spectrum Disorders and co-edited The American Psychiatric Publishing Textbook of Anxiety Disorders. Professor Hollander is a consultant to Neuropharm and was granted the US Orphan Drug designation for fluoxetine in autism in 1999."

Back to Harry Potter.

What is the name of one of Neuropharm's founders?  Dr. Snape!  Same name as the most evil teacher at Hogwarts in JK Rowling's books. How's that for pulling a rabbit out of the hat? 

Dr. Michael Snape does not sport Potions Master Severus Snape's long, greasy hair. In fact, I do hope that Dr. Snape has NOT devoted his career to developing pharmaceuticals for hair growth, as his glabrous head would undermine his reputation in the field of creating successful drugs. 

It seems that the Neuropharm folks, Eric Hollander's people, are going to be working on their own potion for autism in conjunction with Autism Speaks. (Click the word potion to read the press release.) They even gave the study a name far prettier than "Snape." Sofia, which stands for the Study of Fluoxetine in Autism. 

Fluoxetine, by the way, goes by another commercial name. PROZAC. Eli Lilly's blockbuster drug. Over 21,000,000 prescriptions were written for Prozac/Fluoxetine in 2006. That's a crowd, not an orphan. And this is the same drug that comes with the potential side effect of driving children to darkest depression and even to attempt suicide. (Hmmm, I wonder if a certain highly compensated Executive Director will enroll her child in the study and save herself the effort of driving off that bridge?)

Autism Speak's big magic trick is to "expedite drug trials" using a well known, previously tested psychiatric drug on children with autism, that just so happens to have been designated an orphan drug for its Chairman of Treatment. The details of that designation by the FDA in 1998 are here.

Orphan drugs are designated for conditions that are RARE, and unlikely to get funding from companies because of a limited market. Autism wasn't rare in 1998. It was increasing at an alarming rate.

Did Eric Hollander have a crystal ball to see the trend to today's 1 in 150 diagnosis rate and envision a jackpot whereby Prozac would become a treatment for hundreds of thousands of children? If so, why would he EVER want to see autism disappear? 

I think this possible conflict of interest is black magic at its worst.  It's AS playing three card Monty. You know who wins in that card trick?  The dealer.

I'll give my three girls wing of bat and eye of newt first.

Thanks to Lenny Schafer's Evidence of Harm Yahoo Group one of the most active and engaging autism groups on the web for the heads up.

Kim Stagliano is editor of The Rescue Post, a Huffington Post blogger and writer. She lives in Connecticut with her husband Mark and their three beautiful daughters, who happen to have autism. You can read her blog here.


Media Scholar

Thanks Kim. My own concern is that this "experimental" drug has HHS sanctioned liability protection thanks to the "Fristmas" present a few years back.

Autism Speaks have begun their form of Blitzkrieg in my state including stormtroopers like this person:

Reading her photo caption it states..."the federal government must make the distinction that autism is a national emergency".

Lenny Schafer

Hi Kim,
Just wanted to add a correction and plug for my list. You have linked for my EOHarm list the home page for the Schafer Autism Report. The link to our list is instead I would warn all who might consider joining that we have a robust exchange of posts about the political world of autism, sometimes reaching 4000 posts per month! It is free to join and post, but if I actually collected everyone's two-cents, I'd rake in a cool $80 a month -- enough to cover a prescription of generic Prozac for the cat.
Lenny Schafer

Michelle O'Neil

"Say, lets mandate something that will cause an epidemic, and then lets sell something to "help" with that epidemic!"

"Brilliant! We'll be rich!"

Big Pharma, screwing children coming and going.

They (expert doctor at Kennedy Krieger in Baltimore) wanted to put our child on Prozac when she was THREE. Had we done it , we would never have seen the progress she has made. Her bahavior was our clue as to what was wrong and how to help her. Covering up the problem would have been much easier for us, but she would not have been healing.

I do understand some of these little kiddos have been so physically damaged they would have no quality of life without medications though.

Arlene Massey

Snape? A little evil. A little Good. Dr. Snape? Looks like a decent chap. AS? Jury's out.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)