Regressive Autism
FREE EBook from Nourishing Hope: Nutrition for Every Child!

Dachel Media Review: NYC Flu Vaccine Mandate

Online newsBy Anne Dachel

Read Anne's comments and view the links after the jump.

Dec 11, 2013, ABC7: New York City Board of Health approves mandatory flu shots for kids

Dec 10, 2013, Yeshiva World: Autism Group To Protest Bloomberg's Last-Minute Push for Mandatory Flu Vaccines

Dec 10, 2013, CBS News NYC may mandate flu vaccines for all daycare, preschool students

Dec 10, 2013, Wall Street Journal: NYC Board of Health to Vote on Child Flu Shot Rule


Could New York City school children soon be required to get a flu shot?

With three weeks left in office, that's what Mayor Bloomberg is pushing, and not all parents are happy about it.

Flu vaccines could soon be mandatory for up to 150,000 children in New York City.

The Board of Health will vote on new rules that would require a flu vaccine for all children age 6 months to five years who attend a licensed preschool or daycare. . . .

"We already require children be vaccinated against measles, mumps, whooping cough, chicken pox and this is really adding one vaccine- one we know is important," adds Dr. Varma.

Just like other required vaccines, parents can opt out for medical and religious reasons, but adding one more to the list has some parents angry.

"It takes away informed consent from parents and the ability of parents to make the decision as to what may be the best health choice for their family," said Kim Mack Rosenberg, who is the mother of an autistic child.

A planned protest was cancelled due to weather, but as a mother and attorney, Kim questions the requirement.

Yeshiva World

"The Bloomberg administration is wildly exaggerating the benefit of the flu shot and we think they are wildly underestimating the risks involved with it," said John Gilmore, the executive director of the Autism Action Network, who is organizing Tuesday's protest. "There are risks associated with every medical procedure," he said, citing allergic reactions, toxic mercury used as a preservative and questions as to whether the Board's move is legal given state government jurisdictions."
Mr. Gilmore admitted he doesn't expect the Board's vote to go his way, but he hopes the rally will get Mayor-elect Bill de Blasio's attention, potentially opening the door for a reversal once he takes office in January.

"This is basically to put the mayor-elect [on alert], make him aware that this is an issue that he's going to have to deal with it. It's not going to go away," Mr. Gilmore told Politicker. "He is kind of doing this in a stealth fashion. He just proposed this about 6 weeks ago. I don't think there was any announcement."

CBS News

Under the proposal, a daycare or preschool can choose to exclude a child from their facility if he or she doesn't get the vaccine. If the facility does not keep up to date vaccination records for its kids, it could be subject to a fine.

Mandating a flu vaccine for young children is uncommon. Varma noted that only New Jersey and Connecticut have similar requirements for some schools. . . .

The only allowable exemptions are medical, when people have rare side effects to vaccines or conditions that prevent them from receiving one, or religious, which would have to be verified by a religious official.

New York State does not allow philosophical exemptions, such as over fears of vaccine side effects. Varma said that's a good thing, since philosophical differences were behind some reported upticks in diseases like measles for some parts of the country.

Wall Street Journal

Some parents and anti-vaccine activists, though, are fighting the initiative, which would apply to children ages six months to 59 months, which is nearly 5 years old.

If approved, the measure would go into effect in 2014, and children would need to get a flu shot by Dec. 31 of each year.

The measure comes after four New York City children died from the flu last year, a number described as higher than expected by Jay Varma, the city's deputy commissioner for disease control.. . .

The proposal, one of the final health initiatives of Mayor Michael Bloomberg, is being championed by some parents and advocates, including Richard Kanowitz, president of Families Fighting Flu, who lost his daughter at age 4 to the flu.

Mr. Kanowitz, who recently moved to Westchester County, said his organization has been advocating for the Bloomberg measure.

"Somebody gave my daughter the flu," Mr. Kanowitz said, "and had she gotten the vaccine, she would probably be here."

But a group of parents have been rallying against the shots. John Gilmore, the executive director of the Autism Action Network, said his child has neurological damage as a result of several vaccinations administered at once.

Is this the future for school districts around the country?  

Next year will it be preschool to 12th grade in NYC schools?

Someone needs to answer the questions the media should be asking:

Are school districts/boards of health ALSO indemnified against damage suits if a child gets sick following this mass vaccination?

Is Bloomberg willing to assume liability for side effects?

Are parents going to be told that no one is legally liable here?

Anne Dachel is Media Editor for Age of Autism.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Jim Thompson

"Can people receiving the nasal spray flu vaccine pass the vaccine viruses to others?
...Data indicate that both children and adults vaccinated with nasal spray can shed vaccine viruses after vaccination..."

See .

Bob Moffitt

ABC news: "The Board of Health will vote on new rules that would require a flu vaccine for all children age 6 months to five years who attend a licensed preschool or daycare. . ."

That statement is not true .. the "new rules" only apply to those children who attend a "licensed preschool or daycare".

Which means .. if you have the financial means and opportunity .. such as .. a high priced residence outside NYC limits .. or .. Mayor Bloomberg who is about to become a first-time proud grandfather in a few weeks .. that allows HIM to avoid enrolling HIS "toddler" grandchild in a "licensed preschool or daycare" .. HIS grandchild will NOT be required to receive the annual flu shot.

Which means .. even if Mayor Bloomberg believes his new grandchild should receive annual flu vaccines .. that will be HIS decision .. unlike those parents who do not have the Mayor's financial resources or opportunity to avoid enrolling their child in licensed preschool or daycare.

Anyone remember former British PM Tony Blair's refusal to acknowledge if his own child had received the dreaded MMR in Great Britain?

All Tony had to do was say "Yes, my child received the MMR just as I expect all other children to do" .. but .. claiming "privacy" .. he refused to make that clear statement.

Anyone remember former President George W. Bush stating he did not receive his annual flu shot because .. being the altruistic sole he is .. he wanted someone who is at a higher risk of the flu to have the shot instead.

As Ronald Reagan once said: "The nine most terrifying words in the English language are: "I'm from the government and I'm here to help".


Re the ABC article above:
"During the public comment period, the city received 249 letters opposing the proposed law, but if finalized the flu vaccine would be required for children as of December 31, 2014."

IF it's true that only 249 citizens in a population of 8.3 million wrote to oppose the law, that is pathetic.


Today the Minnesota Department of Health held a Flu Twitter Chat, with a moderator from the Minneapolis Star Tribune newspaper. That information-control role feeds concern that newspapers have become marketing arms instead of watchdogs.

I tweeted about these:
(1) The young man who recently died after a flu shot,
(2) A college website stating FluMist makes recipients contagious for 21 days, and
(3) CIDRAP Dr. Michael Osterholm’s 2012 quote berating public health authorities for overstating flu vaccine effectivess.

No direct reply came; instead this lordly pronouncement from Merck vaccine developer Greg Poland, MD (@drgregpoland):
"No one without scientific knowledge should presume to make recommendations to others about medical interventions."

Such grandiose ideation precludes abundant evidence that humanity, from Neanderthals on, has relied on non-scientists when guiding medical treatments. Particularly the billions of parents who make health care choices every day.

Then Dr. Poland also sent this cryptic tweet, with no reference link:
T5: "I published a study showing NO difference in symptoms in adults after flu shot vs placebo #fluchat"

Conspiculously missing from the Department of Health arsenal was information about flu-fighting supplements such as elderberry or bovine lactoferrin.

The one-sided conversation is viewable at

This on the same day that MDH announced a new website: "Immunization Delivery in Pharmacy Settings." One can only imagine the vaccine delivery settings that will follow.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)